Recently I was lucky to run my new game, When the Dark is Gone, with four of the very finest Role-Players I know.
It was a short session but was incredibly good in a number of ways…
– Exceptional Role-Playing from all the Players…check
– Successful Proof of Concept for my two goals….check
– Great feedback which was both ego-boosting and helped clarify the game immensely…check..check…check
We got through character creation fairly smoothly although as the Therapist I ensured it took no longer than an hour. I decided that the purely reflective nature of the Therapist doesn’t extend to the pre-game prepping and so took an active role in suggesting ideas and twists for the problems and relationships of the party.
We established some clear out of character ground rules. Firstly a list of subjects to be avoided (one of the players had a phobia we didn’t want to trigger). Secondly that if anyone felt the game was too intense they could get up and leave the room at any time – but by stating “I need to take a break” it meant that they were going out of character and did not want anyone to follow them IC. With these house rules in mind the session began.
Very soon I encountered the first major challenge of the Therapist role.
Less is more.
In traditional games the GM monitors pacing and when awkward silences happen it is their job to fill the gap with noise. In WTDIG the opposite is true. The Therapist’s role is to say the minimum necessary to help the players draw out the story. Sometimes this means allowing awkward silences to continue. When I hit the first awkward silence I made a decision – I would allow the silence to continue for 10 beats longer than I was comfortable with. This is when the magic happened. Firstly awkward silences are quite normal in real therapy sessions. This lent a sense of realism which helped the immersion aspect. Secondly by allowing an awkward silence to continue, eventually one of the players couldn’t take it any more and started talking. By this point the pressure had been increased nicely so that whatever they blurted out was usually more interesting and led to better stories and conversations.
Still it was a completely new way of GMing and very difficult. It required me to relearn the norms of GMing for this particular game. In fact I am going to create a new term to describe this style – it is not GMIng it is GFing – Game Facilitator.
The other big difference I noticed was in attempting to end the game. Unlike most games with WTDIG there is no planned end-of-level boss, no deliberate climatic scene you are moving towards. The rhythm of WTDIG is totally different and it is likely you will find no obvious end point. Instead of trying to force a conclusion I simply used time. I had a player needing to leave at midnight and so I wrapped up at 11.50pm. In Character I announced that the Therapy session was nearly over and could we just take five minutes to go round the room and have everyone tell the group one thing which they learned today which was helpful.
This last question was to give everyone a small sense of closure and was, I think, vital.
The players enjoyed the short play test and the session was just as emotional and as intense as I hoped. I felt very invested in their personal stories as the Therapist which was unexpected but awesome. I got some great feedback which has mostly gone into WTDIG version 2 (already published here) and now have many other play tests being planned to further develop the game.
There was one aspect of the session which was completely unexpected for me – this is easily a prep-less campaign setting. All the players felt they could have done more sessions and I could see how the sessions would build up on each other to create more tension and more pressure. Next time I test this game I’ll be doing it as a 6 session campaign…and if I can run an emotional, immersive yet prep-less campaign I’ll be a very happy Admiral.
Top tip – mood music during character creation was great (Depeche Mode and Portishead) but I made a point of turning it off when we timed in. This made the contrast with the awkward silences more apparent and was much better for it!